2016-06-06

Hong Kong Debate Open

Motions for Hong Kong Debate Open

8th Hong Kong Debate Open 2017

R1: I want your money

THBT skilled migrants should be made to pay tax to their countries of origin

R2: Beyonce

THS Beyonce’s celebration of black liberation groupe that endorse and use violence as a strategy

R3:

(info) Odious debt  is the legal doctrine that holds that the national debt incurred by a regime for purposes that do not serve the intersets of the nation, shoud not be enforceable

THS the doctrine of odious debt

R4:Life online

(info slide)

A 宅男 is an individual heavily involved in interner culture and online social spaces. As a result, he/she is almost entirely disconnected from real life

THBT it is legitimate lifestyle gor individuals to be a 宅男(Zhai Nan)

R5:

 

7th Hong Kong Debate Open 2016
R1:
TH prefers a world where the Nobel Prize for Literature is directed by a representative panel of ordinary humans rather than experts
R2:
THBT states who stayed neutral throughout WWⅡ should pay reparations to the victims of Nazi aggression
R3:
THW limit the building of high-value residential and commercial properties in urban areas
R4:
TH celebrates the rise of pro-independence politicians in Hong Kong
R5:
THBT intellectuals in universities in the developing world should prioritize social activism over academic research
R6:
THBT it is in the West’s interest for Assad to decisively win in the Syrian Civil War
R7:
THBT communities should be allowed to vote for the removal of police forces in their areas
Quarter Final:
THBT the American government should cut all political and military ties with the Duterte administration
Semi Final:
THBT the Catholic Church should not accept any financial support from morally reprehensible sources (e.g. drug lords, dictators etc)
Grand Final:
THW allow buying and selling babies

6th Hong Kong Debate Open 2015
Round 1:
This House would require MNCs to appoint/hire persons under 35 for at least 30% of positions in their Boards of Directors and upper management HKDO 2015
Round 2:
The House believes that the feminist should support ‪#‎ShoutYourAbortion‬ (#ShoutYourAbortion is a viral hashtag meant to encourage women to speak up about their abortions. HKDO 2015
Round 3:
This house believes that the West should replace Saudi Arabia with Iran as its primary partner in the Middle East
Round 4:
THBT the state should provide poor students with full scholarships AND pay them at least the minimum wage to get college degrees as a major part of its poverty alleviation strategy
Round 5:
Info: Microagression refers to a subtle but offensive comment or action directed at a minority or other non dominant group
TH regrets the strategy of publicly shaming people for micro aggressions
Round 6:
THBT ASEAN(Association of Southeast Nations) should sanction its members for environmental disasters that have international effects.
Octo-Finals:
This House Believes That states should financially incentivize intermarriage between different ethnicities
Quarter-Finals:
This House Regrets the dominant narrative of women as non-violent and vulnerable in conflicts and humanitarian crises
Semi-Finals:
This House Would ban religious proselytization in public places
Grand Final:
THBT individuals should vote for the candidate that they most prefer regardless of that candidate’s chances of winning.

5th Hong Kong Debate Open 2014

(Round 1)
This house believes that all states should STOP memorialization of their war deaths

(Round 2)
This house would abolish retirement age

(Round 3)
This house believes that employment insurance should cover cryopreservation in their health insurance policies

(Round 4)
This house believes that western liberal democracies do not have the right to stop their citizens from joining the Islamic State

(Round 5)
This house regrets the trend of couples using civilian spyware applications such as Dr. Fone, Spyera, and FlexiSpy that allow users to track phones, text messages and all media and applications on the phone

(Round 6)
This house would require companies to have a minimum percentage of employees without college/undergraduate degrees in their core functions

(Octo-Finals)
This house believes that schools should actively promote atheism in their curriculum

(Quarters-Finals)
This house believes that the 3rd world should not use the exportation of labor as a strategy for development

(Semi-Finals)
This house would not allow news outlets to endorse political candidates

(Grand Final)
This house believes that it is time for the West to accept/allow Iran’s development of nuclear technology




4th Hong Kong Debate Open 2013

R1:
We, as the Iranian people, Would not give up our nuclear weapons ambition.
R2:
A terrorist has planted highly lethal explosives within the US. The US has captured the terrorist and has tortured him for the locations of the bombs, but does not respond. The interogator states that the only remaning way to make the terrorist talk is to torture his children in front of the terrorist. In this situation,
THW make it official policy to torture the terrorist’s family members for crucial information
R3:
THBT governments of secular liberal democracies have an obligation to censor in parts or in whole Holy Scriptures which openly support violence and overt discrimination against minorities
R4:
THW allow juries to return a verdict of non-guilty if they determine that they find the decision to be in the public interest
R5:
In times of economic need, THBT states should sell and/or mortgage their national treasures and monuments
R6:
THBT environmentalists should cooperate with corporations to achieve their goals

OF:
THBT developing nations that receive aid and have uneven levels of development should not be providing development aid to other countries
QF:
THW abandon the system of voting Members of Parliament on a geographical basis and instead vote them on the basis of professions and interest groups
SF:
THBT the Palestinians should abandon their claim for an independent state and instead opt for a civil rights struggle
GF:
THBT states should not instill nationalism through the education system

3rd Hong Kong Debate Open 2012

R1:
THW privatize the police.
R2:
THBT the increasing participation of women in violent sports is good for women.
R3:
THW pay drug addicts to get sterilized.
R4:
THW ban positive depictions of former dictators and convicted war criminals.
R5:
THBT the withdrawal of forces of foreign states from a state in which they intervened should be subject to a referendum by the people of that state. (e.g. people of Afghanistan voting on the withdrawal of foreign forces)
R6:
THW ban privately owned vehicles for personal use.
Pre-QF:
THBT states with ageing populations should accept more immigrants instead of providing incentives for their citizens to have more children.
QF:
THW make shareholders legally liable for environmental damage and labour abuse by the companies they invest in.
SF:
THBT the state should not issue operating licences to religious schools that do not acknowledge and teach the supremacy of secular processes and values.
GF:
THW ban the publication of pre-election survey/poll results during the election period.




2nd Hong Kong Debate Open 2011

R1:
THW ban the participation of children in clinical drug trials.
R2:
THW abolish the minimum wage.
R3:
THW ban religious organizations from establishing schools.
R4:
THS the Occupy Wall Street Movement.
R5:
THW ban all approaches that seek to cure homo sexuality.
R6:
THBT USA should not veto the Palestine bid for statehood at the UN.
pre-QF:
THS the use of drones.
QF:
THBT companies should hold liable in their home countries for environmental damage in other countries.
SF:
THW ban agencies that broker international marriages.
GF:
TH regrets the policy of assassinating terrorist leaders instead of bringing them to trials.

1st Hong Kong Debate Open 2010

R1:
THW force corporations to produce advertisements that feature only people who represent the region they are advertising in
R2:
THBT awarding Nobel Peace Prize to Liu Xiaobo harms the human rights situation in China rather than improves it
R3:
THW not allow law enforcement officers to impersonate minors to entrap paedophieles online
R4:
THW ban artificial reproductive technologies (such as IVF, surrogacy, sperm banks, etc.) to force people to adopt
R5:
THW recruit rebel soldiers into state armies in post-conflict regions
R6:
THBT government reconstruction aid to disaster victims who live in disaster-prone areas should be conditional on their relocation to safer areas
QF:
THBT governments should subsidize private house ownership
SF:
THW subject religions to anti-gender-discrimination laws
GF:
This House supports the violant removal of corrupt officials by citizens in weak democracies